I read somewhere a remark from an editor that went something like this: "I know it's an amateur's work when I can't smell anything."
That line really stuck with me. Because words are a visual medium, and when I write I am visualizing the scene and translating it into words, I forget to include the other senses.
I'm sure I'm not alone in this. I have seen entire stories where the hero doesn't hear, smell, touch, or taste anything. When you read them, you can tell there is something missing -- they just don't feel "alive". It's like watching from the sidelines instead of being there and experiencing it.
Most of us manage to slip in some sounds, and occasionally some tactile sensations, but rarely do we stick in odors. Yet smells create the most immediate emotions.
Another thing I read was you should appeal to at least 3 senses in a scene to make it seem real. It can be any 3 of the 5.
When I look at professional writing, I see this. The best authors put you in their scenes by serving you a sensual buffet.
Re:We have five, count 'em FIVE, senses
Another thought: there is considerable technique involved in putting sensual impressions into a scene. You can't just start listing off descriptions of everything every time the setting changes. I tried that once, and I found I was over-describing everything. It was worse than not describing it at all.
You have to carefully choose which details to bring out, and decide when the characters notice them. The details should be the minimum necessary to put the reader in the scene, and they should come out when it makes sense.
Maybe the hero stops at the entrance to a room and takes it all in before he enters. Or maybe he enters first and smells something odd, then looks around more carefully. Or maybe he notices the smell later. Or maybe there is a noise that occurs after a few seconds, with a vibration that occurs first.
Maybe the hero sees the pale liquid in a vial, holds it up to the light, sniffs it, tries to identify what the smell reminds him of, then dips his finger in it and touches his finger to his tongue. This becomes an opportunity to draw out the sensations a bit, to really put the reader in the scene.
I'm not a complete idiot -- some parts are missing.
Re:We have five, count 'em FIVE, senses
Ahem ... there are six senses, Eddy. (Think deeply before insisting that there are only five.)
To err is human. I am not human.
Re:We have five, count 'em FIVE, senses
lol....that's gonna bug the hell out of me now, Greg. but don't tell me just yet, i have a feeling i'm missing something really obvious. :oops:
Re:We have five, count 'em FIVE, senses
Six senses! Right! I [i]knew[/i] you were going to say that!
I'm not a complete idiot -- some parts are missing.
Re:We have five, count 'em FIVE, senses
Does Common Sense count?
Probably not if so few people have it...
----
Life is a lot like caving: Most of the time you grope around in the dark.
Re:We have five, count 'em FIVE, senses
Oh right, common sense. That makes sense.
I thought I could sense your thoughts with my extra-sense. It didn't work. I'm incensed.
You need to stop bathing for a while. Then I could detect your extra scents.
Otherwise, it's nonsense.
I'm not a complete idiot -- some parts are missing.
Re:We have five, count 'em FIVE, senses
So what is the sixth?
Re:We have five, count 'em FIVE, senses
We humans have a Sense of Humor.
To err is human. I am not human.
Re:We have five, count 'em FIVE, senses
[quote="CyberSavant"]We humans have a Sense of Humor. :lol:[/quote]
Oh, now that is good! Writer's often forget that humans have an innate sense of humor that lets us laugh in the face of adversity. While were on the subject, how many writers take into account that we are undeniably primates, with a need for play, and social structures, et.
Re:We have five, count 'em FIVE, senses
Hmmm...
[quote]We humans have a Sense of Humor.
_________________
To err is human. I am not human.[/quote]
Split personality, maybe?
I'm not a complete idiot -- some parts are missing.
Re:We have five, count 'em FIVE, senses
I love this smell comment. It never occurred to me. Now that it has, I'm noticing the absence or presence of the five physical senses as I read. I've also rewritten some of my own scenes to add more sensory contact for the reader. Yes, I am an untrained amatuer.
Re:We have five, count 'em FIVE, senses
>>Yes, I am an untrained amatuer.
Ahh, Joe, but the simple fact you are engaging in conversation about writing, utilizing this resource, and discovering knew ways to improve your own writing implies you are very much more than an untrained amateur. You are someone who is attempting to improve ones work in an active manner and that is leaps and bounds better than most. Have confidence, for we all had to start at ground zero, and learning to write is a slow and often thankless task.
The writing queue is short. When you feel something's ready, send it off.
----
Life is a lot like caving: Most of the time you grope around in the dark.